Flock cameras are sold as a way to catch car thieves. On the last Sunday in June, one of them found a $155,000 Range Rover with a New Jersey plate, helped police follow it around suburban Minneapolis for two days, and gave four officers a reason to box it in outside a Kohl’s. The car was a manufacturer loaner. Plates on it were never stolen. The driver was a journalist who had spent the previous month telling his readers what a national plate network can do to a stranger — and a clerk 2,000 miles away had typed a matching plate into a crime database without the two small digits in the middle.
What makes this more than a week of outrage is the shape of the mistake: one dropped character at the top of the chain survived four separate chances to be caught, and the only person who paid was the man in the parking lot.
Joel Feder — 4 Squad Cars, Hands on the Holster
Feder runs content and product at The Drive. On June 28 he was running errands with his wife in Plymouth, Minnesota, in a Range Rover loaned by Jaguar Land Rover for review (The Drive). They had just reversed out of the space after returning an Amazon order. Two squad cars came in from the passenger side with lights on; two more arrived from the driver’s side.
He was ordered out, asked whether he was armed, patted down, and separated from his wife while a second group questioned her (FOX 9). The Plymouth police report describes the tactic as “initiated a box and pin on the vehicle.” Weapons stayed holstered. Hands did not leave the holsters.
The officer’s explanation, as FOX 9 recorded it: “The reason you have four cops here is your license plate is registered as a stolen license plate.” The VIN came back clean. It took about an hour of phone calls to JLR before they were released.
The Database — 34 DTM, Minus the ’10’ That Made It His
Feder’s plate reads 34 10 DTM, with the middle digits printed smaller — the format New Jersey uses for manufacturer tags. A second JLR plate, 34 03 DTM, had been reported stolen in California; it was lost by Land Rover during a photo shoot, as Feder later learned (The Drive). That report reached the National Crime Information Center minus the small middle digits. Just 34 DTM.
Flock builds its hotlist from NCIC. When its AI-mekna read Feder’s tag it dropped the “10” and matched the shortened string — and it published a photograph of the plate where the 10 is legible, which the officer did not use to check the full sequence. Both sides of the handoff locked onto the same seven characters. Nobody stole anything, and everybody was certain.
Tim Esterdahl — 3 Days Later, Same Sequence, Different State
Days after Feder’s story ran, another auto journalist, Tim Esterdahl of Pickup Truck + SUV Talk, was pulled over in Scotts Bluff, Nebraska, driving a $105,000 JLR loaner with his 14-year-old in the car. His plate: 34 08 DTM (The Drive). He showed the officers Feder’s article, got no pat-downs, and was released after an hour. The officers who detained Feder had predicted it: JLR has a stack of those loaners circulating, and a hotlist entry missing its middle digits does not expire when the first innocent driver disproves it.
Flock Cameras — 1,427 Alerts in Roseville, 71% Read Wrong
The company’s stated accuracy is 93 of every 100 plates captured, a figure critics now quote from a court filing rather than a marketing page (Institute for Justice). FOX 9 did the arithmetic that matters: Flock says 20 billion vehicles pass its cameras monthly, so a 93% read rate leaves something near 1.4 billion captures a month carrying no information or the wrong information (FOX 9). At least 27 cases since 2018 are documented by the IJ — most since 2023 — in which an error put an innocent motorist on the ground, in cuffs or in a cell. A Sherwood, Arkansas, couple were held at gunpoint with their six-week-old alone in the car; a “7” read as a “2” in Toledo ended with a police dog on an innocent man. And in Roseville, California, Flock sent 1,427 alerts over two years with the plates misread in 71% of them.
Garrett Langley — ‘An Alert Is a Lead’
On August 13, Flock founder and CEO Garrett Langley apologised on CNN and announced guardrails: audit monitoring for unusual activity and repeated queries, mandatory case codes for searches, lockouts pending review, a 7-day default retention period, and an offense filter cities can use to limit what other agencies search for (The Drive). Existing customers keep the retention periods they already had.
Flock’s statement on Feder’s stop was a defence of process: “an alert is a lead, not a conclusion, which should be confirmed by an officer.” It describes a division of labour where the vendor sells the match and the officer owns the error. None of the August package changes how a plate is read. Retention governs how long a record lives; case codes govern who may query it. Neither touches the moment the AI-mekna decides 34 10 DTM is 34 DTM. Langley’s stated ambition in the same period was to grow from 7,000 cities to all 17,000.
Plymouth — 16 Cameras Down, One Mayor Alone
On September 22 the Plymouth City Council voted to end the contract and take down all 16 permanent cameras. Mayor Jeffry Wosje was the only dissenter, weighing “the ability to keep our residents safe and catch the bad guys” against “basically the bad PR that Flock has” (MPR News). The council’s reasoning was not the typo but who else can reach the data: Plymouth had already stopped sharing with about 36 agencies after northern searches turned out to serve immigration enforcement, which Minnesota law does not allow this data to do. A Washington Post investigation found authorities have accused at least 50 law enforcement officers of misusing that data, including to track women they knew.
Alexandria — 61 Cameras ‘Off’ That Kept Flashing
Alexandria, Virginia, decommissioned its 61 Flock cameras on October 30. More than a week later, residents filmed the units still firing red and blue light at passing traffic. Police say the hardware is solar-powered and motion-triggered, so it can activate without recording or transmitting (WUSA9). Maybe. But a resident with the group De-Flock framed it correctly: the city is asking the public to trust the police that nothing is kept, and to trust the vendor that nothing is sent. Two trusts, no switch on the pole.
The Ledger — 10 Governments, $615,000, a 60% Theft Drop
Since summer, at least 10 local governments and police departments have moved to curb, restrict or end their Flock use — among them Monroe, Ohio; Richmond, Virginia; Lansing, Michigan; Asheville, North Carolina; and Colorado’s El Paso County Sheriff’s Office (TechCrunch). League City, Texas, settled it by public vote. Florida barred plate readers from state highways; Texas paused state funding. Perris, California, suspended a two-year, $615,000 contract covering 104 cameras on November 10 (KVCR), and Yakima’s council voted 5-2 to ban live Flock cameras on city property (Yakima Herald-Republic).
The other side deserves the same space. At the Perris meeting the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department reported motor vehicle theft down 60% since 2022. That is the real trade: a measurable drop in stolen cars, bought with a network that will, at some documented rate, put the wrong person on the ground in front of an officer who believes his screen.
Axel’s Take — the Typo Was Never the Bug
Everyone involved has been taught the wrong lesson. Feder’s stop gets filed as a clerk’s keystroke and an officer’s skipped check. Fix those two behaviours and nothing in the system changes, because its product is a match, and a match is only as good as the worst link that produced it: a reader that cannot say how sure it is, a database that lost the digits separating one human being from another, and an officer with a photograph that disproves the alert in his hand and no habit of looking.
Feder got out in an hour because he could phone a car company on a Sunday and because his wife’s story matched his. A man with a worse phone, a worse job or a shakier voice does not get the same hour. That is the measurable thing — 27 people on record since 2018, four squad cars, one dropped digit, and a suburb that had to cancel a contract to learn what its own police force did with the data.
The cameras Plymouth voted out are coming off the poles. The 61 in Alexandria were “off” for nine days while they kept flashing at traffic. Cancelling a Flock contract does not switch anything off unless somebody climbs the pole.
Sources: The Drive, FOX 9, MPR News, Institute for Justice, TechCrunch, WUSA9, KVCR, Yakima Herald-Republic.