The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals spent Wednesday morning deciding whether you will ever be allowed to learn that your novel, your photographs or your medical history was fed to Grok, and the company arguing that you should stay ignorant did not have a comfortable hour. xAI wants California’s training-data disclosure law thrown out as unconstitutional. A federal judge already refused to stop the law. Now three appellate judges get the last word on whether the ingredient list stays sealed.
The argument ran in Pasadena before Judges Johnnie Rawlinson, Milan Smith and Danielle Forrest in X.AI LLC v. Bonta, No. 26-1591, and the court has not ruled. Bloomberg Law’s reporters came away describing a panel that was openly skeptical of the company’s position; MLex reported that the judges pushed both sides rather than handing either one a win. Reuters covered the same argument the day it happened. What no one in that room disputed is the thing that matters outside it: nobody has to tell a Californian that their work is in the training set unless this law survives.
Judge Johnnie Rawlinson — The Question xAI Brought No Answer For
Rawlinson put the whole appeal into a single sentence worth more than xAI’s brief. As Bloomberg Law reported it, she asked whether it is not entirely reasonable for a government to want its citizens to know, before they use a system, what information has been poured into it. That is not a hard question. It is the question a person asks before drinking something handed to them by a stranger.
xAI’s answer is that the disclosure is compelled speech and that the summaries would hand competitors a map of its trade secrets. Convenient, because a trade secret you cannot describe in a high-level summary is a trade secret so fragile it should not survive contact with a competitor’s hiring manager.
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals — Twelve Topics Is Not a Trade Secret
The law is Assembly Bill 2013, in force since January 1, 2026. It does not demand the training corpus. It demands a public summary covering at least twelve topics, among them where the data came from, whether it includes copyrighted material, whether it includes personal information, and whether any of it was bought or licensed. The district court record is laid out here. Twelve categories, one document, no source code, no weights, no secret sauce.
U.S. District Judge Jesus Bernal denied xAI a preliminary injunction on March 4, ruling the company had not shown a likelihood of success on the merits. That is the ruling on appeal. This is the first time a federal appellate court has weighed a state AI transparency mandate, which means the panel is not just deciding California’s law. It is deciding whether any state gets to ask this question at all.
xAI filed the underlying suit on December 29, 2025, three days before the statute took effect, against Attorney General Rob Bonta. The complaint’s three pillars — uncompensated taking of trade secrets, compelled speech, unconstitutional vagueness — are the same three arguments every large lab would raise if a legislature ever got this far again. Which is exactly why the panel’s tone matters more than any single line of questioning.
Rob Bonta — The State Already Won Once and Gets to Keep Arguing
California’s position is narrower than the company’s press cycle suggests: the summaries are commercial speech about a commercial product, and the state can require a seller to tell buyers what is in the box. Bonta’s office defended the statute at the district level and defended it again Wednesday, and it did not have to argue alone. Seven amicus briefs filed in July backed the state, from the Center for AI and Digital Policy to the Knight First Amendment Institute to the Center for Investigative Reporting.
That last name is the one to hold onto. A nonprofit newsroom filed a brief in favor of a law that would let its reporters check what an AI company swallowed, because reporters who cannot check are reduced to quoting press releases about a system they cannot see. Transparency is not an abstraction to a newsroom. It is the difference between a story and a rewrite.
Marc Rotenberg — Transparency Costs the Companies Nothing They Didn’t Already Spend
Rotenberg, who led the Center for AI and Digital Policy’s brief, has spent years arguing that California’s disclosure rules travel: what the largest state requires tends to become the national floor, because compliance is cheaper than building two products. His point cuts against xAI’s urgency. A company that already assembles a data inventory to train, license and defend a model is being asked to publish the table of contents, not the recipe.
The human cost lands on the other side of the ledger. A photographer in Fresno whose portfolio sits inside a model’s weights has no subpoena, no audit right and no notification. The twelve-topic summary is the only instrument that would ever tell her, and it tells her at the level of a category rather than a file. xAI is fighting to make sure she never gets even that much.
Grok — The Model Whose Ingredient List Nobody Is Allowed to Read
Name the system, because accountability needs a noun. This is about Grok, xAI’s model, and about the company’s judgment that the public cannot be trusted with a summary of what built it. No other major lab has publicly joined the challenge, which is its own kind of statement: the industry’s giants would rather comply than be seen arguing that their customers should know less. Startup Fortune noted that isolation in its coverage of the filing.
There is a version of this story where the panel reverses Bernal, the law falls, and every state legislature that watched gets a clear signal that disclosure mandates are litigable to death. There is another where the Ninth Circuit affirms and the twelve-topic summary becomes the template for a dozen states in two years. Both outcomes were on the table Wednesday. Only one of them requires a company to tell you what it took.
The judges asked their questions, took the case under submission and went to lunch. xAI’s lawyers walked out with the same advantage every well-funded litigant has: time, and the knowledge that delay is a win when the product is already shipping. The photographer in Fresno gets neither.
The ingredient list is not a state secret. It is a label. The only people who fight this hard to keep a label off the box are the ones who know what the label would say.
Sources: Reuters, Bloomberg Law, CAIDP, Startup Fortune.